Call Us: (888) 985-0014
Medicare Education6 min readNovember 15, 2026

Open Enrollment Scams to Ignore — And How to Know Who You’re Really Talking To

Medicare Experts  |  www.yourmedicareexperts.com  |  Educational guide for North Carolina & Southeast seniors

Medicare open enrollment scam alert with an unknown caller on a smartphone and a red warning symbol.

Medicare open enrollment runs through Monday, December 7, and this is the time of year when the phone starts ringing, the texts start arriving, and ads promising “free” benefits show up everywhere. Some of that is ordinary plan marketing. A lot of it is not.

I’m Eric Schofield, a Certified Medicare Insurance Planner (CMIP®) and president of Medicare Experts. I want to walk you through the scams you should hang up on — and a simple way to check that the person offering to help you is actually who they say they are.

Scams to hang up on

Scammers get especially active during open enrollment because they know millions of people are comparing plans. Here are the ones I hear about most, and what to do instead.

  • A call, text, or email “from Medicare” asking for your Medicare number or Social Security number. Medicare does not cold-call, text, or email to ask for or “verify” that information. If you didn’t start the conversation, don’t share it. Hang up and call Medicare yourself at 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), or go directly to Medicare.gov.
  • A threat that your coverage will be cancelled if you don’t act right now. Pressure and fear are hallmarks of a scam. A real coverage decision can wait long enough for you to check it out.
  • An offer of a “new Medicare card,” especially a plastic or chip card, or a card with “special” benefits. Your Medicare card is not being replaced that way, and Medicare does not issue special-benefit cards over the phone.
  • “Free” gifts, cash cards, or medical equipment in exchange for your Medicare number. A legitimate plan does not need your Medicare number as the price of a prize.
  • A text with a link or a QR code, or a search ad that looks like the official Medicare site. Don’t click links in unexpected messages. If you searched online, look for an “Ad” or “Sponsored” label, and check that you are actually on a .gov website. Type Medicare.gov into your browser yourself.

If a call feels rushed, scary, or too good to be true, hang up. You can always call Medicare back on the official number, or talk with someone you can actually look up.

You wouldn’t take this kind of advice from just anyone

Here’s a comparison I use with people all the time. If you were hiring someone to help with your retirement savings, you wouldn’t casually take advice from a person who isn’t a Certified Financial Planner (CFP®). You’d want someone who earned that credential, and whom you can look up.

The same standard belongs with your health coverage. You wouldn’t see a doctor who isn’t licensed. Your Medicare decision can affect your doctors, your prescriptions, and your costs for a full year. It’s worth being just as careful about who you trust with it.

That is not a knock on every licensed insurance agent — many are conscientious and well trained. It is a reminder that you should be able to verify who you’re dealing with, instead of trusting a surprising phone call or a pop-up ad.

Look us up. Here’s the link.

I’m a Certified Medicare Insurance Planner (CMIP®). That’s a professional designation from the Society of Medicare Planners, not a marketing slogan and not a claim that I’m “certified by Medicare.” Medicare does not certify agents. A CMIP® designation requires years of licensed experience, years of annual Medicare training, high ethical standards, and it has to be renewed each year.

You don’t have to take my word for it. You can look us up yourself on the Society’s public directory: certifiedmedicareinsuranceplanner.org/agents-list.

I’m listed there. So is my vice president, Jordan Thomas, who is also a CMIP®, and my executive vice president, Isaac Guerrette, who holds the CMIR™ designation. Our advising team holds professional designations from the Society of Medicare Planners.

If you want another way to confirm a designation, you can call the Society at (833) FOR-CMIP (833-367-2647) or email info@certifiedmedicareinsuranceplanner.org.

A real advisor will welcome that kind of check. A scammer will not.

What a real advisor will never do

Whether you work with us or with someone else, these are fair lines to hold:

  • Ask you for your Medicare number or Social Security number on an unexpected call, text, email, or at your door.
  • Rush you to enroll before you’ve had time to review your options.
  • Promise a gift, prize, or “free” benefit in exchange for your personal information.
  • Claim to be calling “from Medicare,” or describe themselves as “Medicare-certified.” Medicare does not certify agents.
  • Get upset if you want to hang up and call back on a number you found yourself.

If you think you’ve already been scammed

Act promptly, and use official numbers and sites — not a callback number from the suspicious message.

  • Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), or report Medicare fraud online at Medicare.gov.
  • Report it to the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
  • If you have a Medicare Advantage or Medicare drug plan, you can also call the Investigations Medicare Drug Integrity Contractor (I-MEDIC) at 1-877-7SAFERX (1-877-772-3379).
  • In North Carolina, you can get free, unbiased counseling from SHIIP, the Seniors’ Health Insurance Information Program, at 855-408-1212.
  • Review your Medicare claims for charges you don’t recognize. A secure account at Medicare.gov makes that easier.

If you’d rather talk with us

Medicare Experts is an independent brokerage. We are not Medicare, and we are not a government agency. We help people in North Carolina and across the Southeast compare their options in plain language, and a conversation with us doesn’t cost you a consultation fee.

Open enrollment ends Monday, December 7. If you’d like help reviewing your 2027 options, visit yourmedicareexperts.com, book a time at yourmedicareexperts.com/book, or call us at 888-985-0014 or 919-390-1880.

A quick note

This article is for education, not personalized advice. Medicare Experts, a division of Optimum Financial Brokerage, Inc., is not affiliated with the federal Medicare program, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), or any government agency. Plan availability and benefits vary. For official Medicare information, visit Medicare.gov or call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227).